Understanding as Memorisation: Insights from Sweller’s New Paper

John Sweller’s recent paper has sparked an intriguing debate in the educational community regarding the nature of understanding in relation to memorisation. Discussed by Carl Hendrick in his newsletter The Learning Dispatch on 31 October 2026, the paper argues that understanding is not distinct from memorisation; rather, it is a sophisticated form of it, where knowledge is stored as interconnected elements. This perspective refines Dan Willingham’s assertion that understanding might merely be “remembering in disguise.”
The Concept of Element Interactivity
A central notion in Sweller’s research is element interactivity, a term originating from Cognitive Load Theory. In essence, element interactivity describes how knowledge components interact within the mind. For example, in a mathematical equation, a sign modifies the action required on a term; similarly, a word in a sentence derives its meaning from its context. This indicates that element interactivity is an inherent property of knowledge rather than a characteristic of the learner alone. Consequently, a novice might successfully memorise isolated facts without being able to synthesize this information, illustrating that rote memorisation and true understanding are complementary rather than opposing forces.
Reframing Expertise in Learning
The implications of Sweller's findings extend further into how we define expertise. Sweller argues that experts do not possess fundamentally different cognitive processes; instead, they integrate numerous elements into cohesive units. This allows skilled teachers to intuitively solve complex problems quickly. Furthermore, understanding is often domain-specific. We do not consider the concept of "understanding" when referring to discrete facts, such as dates or capital cities, which do not inherently contain relational aspects to grasp fully. Hendrick suggests that “teaching for understanding” is not a one-size-fits-all skill; rather, it varies significantly across subjects. One educator highlighted that connections can indeed be taught explicitly, indicating that the discourse on this topic remains vibrant and unresolved.
Practical Implications for Education
For educators and students preparing for exams, Sweller's insights offer concrete strategies: sequence educational content to match working memory capacity, make the relationships within knowledge visible, use analogies and narratives to build connections, and focus on assessing the relationships between ideas rather than mere recall. These strategies provide a robust framework for advocating evidence-based approaches within didactic units and practical applications.
In conclusion, Sweller's paper pushes us to reconsider our understanding of learning and teaching methodologies, emphasizing the importance of interconnectedness in mastering educational content. As the conversation evolves, it will be essential for educators to adapt and find innovative ways to foster deep understanding among learners.